James Hale shot and killed 25 Dec. 1886.
TERRITORY OF ARIZONA                        Springerville, A.T.

SS
COUNTY OF APACHE                           December 25, 1886

The People of the Territory of Arizona send Greetings:

     To W.S. Atchison, A.J. Cooper, J.V. Brighton, A. Long, Gustav Becker, Justinano Baca, P.H. Snow, Elisha Everett, and A.A. DeWitt.

     We command you, that all and singular business and excuses being laid aside, you be and appear before the undersigned, Acting Coroner of the Precinct of Springerville, County of Apache, Territory of Arizona, at West and Brighton's Saloon on the 25th day of December, 1886, at two o'clock P.M. then and there to serve as Juror's in a certain Inquisition now pending before said Coroner, and herein fail not, or answer to the contrary at your peril.

Given under my hand this 25th day of December, 1886
John T. Hogue
Justice of the Peace
And Acting Coroner of Said County and Territory

The People of the Territory of Arizona send Greetings:

     To John Cook, Luther Martin, Eugene Singleton, Chas. A. Wood, Wm. Wood, J.W. Graham, Simeon Davis, J.W. Talbott, Geo. G. Graham and Jas. R. Woolsey and Elisha Everett.

     We command you, that all and singular business and excuses being laid aside, you be and appear before the undersigned, Acting Coroner of the Precinct of Springerville, at West and Brighton's Saloon, in Springerville, at two o'clock P.M. then and there, to testify and give evidence in a certain Inquisition now pending before said Coroner, and herein fail not, or answer to the contrary at your peril.

Given under my hand this twenty fifth day of December, 1886.
John T. Hogue
Justice of the Peace Acting Coroner
County of Apache
Territory of Arizona

TERRITORY OF ARIZONA                      Springerville, A.T.
SS
COUNTY OF APACHE                            December 25, 1886
Office of the Justice of the Peace
And Acting Coroner
County of Apache
Territory of Arizona

I hereby certify that I served the witness's summons on the twenty fifth day of December, 1886, on W.S. Atchison, A.J. Cooper, J.V. Brighton, Anthony Long, Gustav Becker, Justinano Baca, P.H. Snow, Elisha Everett and A.A. DeWitt, being the Jurymen named in said Summons, at the County of Apache, by showing said Summons to each Jurymen personally, and informing each of them of the contents thereof.

John T. Hogue
Justice of the Peace
And Acting Coroner
December 25, 1886

This is to certify that I served the written subponea on the twenty fifth day of December, 1886, on John Cook, Luther Martin, Eugene Singleton, Chas. A. Wood, Wm. Wood, J.W. Graham, Simeon Davis, J.W. Talbott, Geo. G. Graham, J.R. Woolsey and Elisha Everett, being the witness's named in said subponea, at the County of Apache, by showing the original to each of said witness's. personally, and informing each of them of the contents thereof.

John T. Hogue
Justice of the Peace
And Acting Coroner

DUPLICATE PAPERS

In the matter of an Inquisition held upon the body of James Hale deceased, on the 25th day of December, 1886. The original papers in this matter were stolen on the evening of Dec. 26th, 1886.

John T. Hogue
Justice of the Peace
And Acting Coroner
Springerville Precinct
County of Apache
Territory of Arizona

TERRITORY OF ARIZONA                    Springerville, A.T.
SS
COUNTY OF APACHE                  December 25, 1886

In the Justice Court, Springerville Precinct, County of Apache, Territory of Arizona.

In the matter of the Inquisition upon the body of James Hale, before John T. Hogue, Justice of the Peace and Acting Coroner.

On the 25th day of December, 1886, I, John T. Hogue, Justice of the Peace, received information that one James Hale had been shot. I immediately summoned a Coroner's Jury under the provisions of the Statute authorizing a Justice of the Peace to act as Coroner. The following Jury was empanelled to-wit:

A.A. DeWitt, W.S. Atchison, A.J. Cooper,J.V. Brighton, Anthony Long, Gustav Becker, Justinano Baca, P.H. Snow and Elisha Everett.  After said Jury had been duly sworn according to Law they proceeded to inspect the body of deceased, James Hale, and ascertained that deceased had been shot with a gun or pistol of (44) forty-four caliber, the ball entering about four inches below the nipple of the right breast and ranging a little downward and lodging just under the skin about four inches under the left shoulder blade.  The ball was cut out by one of the Jurymen and found to be of (44) caliber.  After completing the inspection of the body, the Jury proceeded to examine the following witnesses, Viz: John Cook, Luther Martin, Eugene Singleton, Chas. A. Wood, William Wood. J.W. Graham, Simeon Davis, J.W. Talbott, Geo. G. Graham, Jas. R. Woolsey and Elisha Everett.  After hearing the conflicting testimony of the aboved named witness's, the Coroner's Jury rendered the following verdict, to wit:

DUPLICATE

We the undersigned, The Jurors summoned to appear before

John T. Hogue, the Acting Coroner of the Precinct of Springerville, on the twenty fifth day of December, 1886, to inquire into the cause of the death of James Hale, having been duly sworn according to law, and having made such Inquisition, after inspecting the body, and hearing the testimony adduced, upon our oaths, each and all do say, that we find the deceased was named James Hale, was a native of the United States, aged about fifty nine years, that he came to his death on the twenty fifth day of December, 1886, in this County, by a gun or pistol shot wound by the hand of some person, to the Jury unknown. All of which we duly certify by this Inquisition in writing by us signed, this twenty fifth day of December, 1886.

A.A. DeWitt
Gustav Becker
P.H. Snow
Anthony Long
J.V. Brighton
W.S. Atchison
Elisha Everett
By virtue of the foregoing Inquisition and in accordance with
the requirements of law, I, John T. Hogue, Justice of the Peace
and Acting Coroner, issued the following certificate of death, towit:
CORONERS'S CERTIFICATE OF DEATH
Office of the Acting Coroner
Precinct of Springerville
County of Apache
Territory of Arizona.

I, John T. Hogue, Acting Coroner of the County of Apache, Territory of Arizona, do hereby certify that I held an Inquisition upon the body of James Hale, a native of the United States, aged fifty nine years, at West and Brighton's Saloon in the town of Springerville, on the twenty fifth day of December, 1886. Verdict of the Jury: Death from a gun or pistol shot wound by the hand of some person, to the Jury unknown. And I further certify, that I caused to be interred his body at the Cemetery near Amity, in said County of Apache, on the twenty seventh day of December, 1886.

John T. Hogue
Acting Coroner
of Apache County
In concluding the proceedings of the aforesaid Inquisition, I
hereby place on record the following Certificate to wit:

TERRITORY OF ARIZONA               Springerville, A.T.
SS
COUNTY OF APACHE                 December 27, 1886

Office of the Justice of the Peace Acting Coroner of the County of Apache, Territory of Arizona.

This is to certify that while I, John T. Hogue, Justice of the Peace and Acting Coroner was absent from my office, at supper, on Sunday evening, December 26th, 1886.  All the depositions taken before the coroner's Jury, the verdict of the Jury and the Certificate of Death in the matter of the Inquisition upon the body of James Hale, deceased, were stolen off the table in my office by some person or persons to me unknown.  For this reason the evidence adduced at said Inquisition will not be found among the papers in this matter here with forwarded.

John T. Hogue
Justice of the Peace
December 27, 1886
Acting Coroner's fees
For summoning Jury $3.00   Forward $12.50
For swearing Jury $ .50   For recording 8 folios $ 1.60
For subponeas 11 witness $ .75   For Certificate of Death $ .50
For administering oaths $ .50   For attending burial $ 3.00
For certifying 11 oaths $2.50   For Deposition of witnesses
For filing papers $ .25   Stolen 15 folios $ 3.00
For charge of Jury $2.00   For filing verdict $  .50
$20.35

IN THE JUSTICE COURT, SPRINGERVILLE PRECINCT
COUNTY OF APACHE, TERRITORY OF ARIZONA
THE TERRITORY OF ARIZONA December 26, 1886
               VS CRIMINAL ACTION
J.W. DIMON ALIAS
W.N TIMBERLINE
Complaint on oath having been made before me on the 26th day of December, 1886, by J.R. Woolsey of said Precinct and County, that one J.W. Dimon, alias W.N. Timberline, on the 25th day of December, 1886, at said Precinct in the County of Apache, did assault with intent to kill, and did fire a pistol shot, which resulted in the death of James Hale. In pursuance of said complaint, warrant of arrest was issued on the 26th day of December, 1886, and was placed in the hands of J.R. Woolsey, of said Precinct, with authority to summon aid to make the arrest.  The Defendant in the above action was arrested by J.R. Woolsey and his posse and brought into this Court on the 27th day of December, 1886, in a wounded condition, having been wounded by the Special Constable and his posse in attempting to make his escape.  The Defendant was immediately informed of the charge against him and of his right to the aid of Counsel in every stage of the proceedings against him.  The Defendant plead 'Not Guilty' to the charge against him and asked for an adjournment of the examination to enable him to obtain Counsel.  In consideration of the wounded condition of the prisoner, and of his request for an adjournment this cause adjourned until Wednesday, December, 29th, 1886, at (2) two o'clock P.M. to enable Defendant to procure Counsel and to obtain Medical aid.
December 29th, 1886, 2 o'clock P.M.

On this day and hour, this cause came on for examination.  The District Attorney appeared for the Territory.  Defendant is confined to his bed from the effects of a gun shot wound and is unable to be moved to a place of examination.  Defendant also has no Counsel although he has used due diligence to procure an Attorney.  On motion of Defendant and consent of the District Attorney, the hearing of this cause is continued until the 10th day of January, 1887, at 10 o'clock A.M.  The Defendant committed to the Sheriff of the County of Apache for hearing, January 1st, 1887, and while said hearing was pending, the term of office of the undersigned 
expired.
  John T. Hogue         

Jack Becker's note:    J. R. Woolsey was a son-in-law of James Hale.

Follow the above incident in the newspaper articles:
Killing of 2 More Outlaws
Local News - 1886 
Local News - 1887

From the files of Jack A. Becker.